Showing posts with label Fracking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fracking. Show all posts

Friday, December 11, 2015

BIG CYPRESS IN TROUBLE

From Michelle Gale

Greetings:

This is one of my lengthier posts. Please read it all because even if you don’t attend Tuesday’s meeting at Big Cypress, you will have an opportunity to participate in a meaningful way in this campaign against turning a national preserve into an oilfield.

On Tuesday, December 8th, the National Park Service will hold a public meeting from 5:30 to 7:00 pm at the Big Cypress Welcome Center, 33000 Tamiami Trail East, in Ochopee in response to two years’ worth of requests from citizens concerned about Burnett Oil’s proposal to do seismic testing on 70,454 acres of Big Cypress National Preserve.

Environmental groups are hosting a press conference outside the Welcome Center beginning at 5:00. There will be an open mic at which attendees can articulate their comments to the Park Service and a petition delivery.  

The meeting itself will open with a 15-minute presentation by the National Park Service outlining the three possible alternatives for Big Cypress:

·     Seismic survey by vibroseis trucks,

·     Seismic survey by dynamite, and

·     No seismic survey

Burnett Oil proposes to use vibroseis trucks. This would entail 60,000-pound trucks criss-crossing the Preserve in groups of three on cut lines (essentially, roads) up to 50 feet wide, vibrating large plates against the ground to generate seismic signals that are indicative of local geology, while helicopters hover overhead and generators run—in the heart of pristine wetlands set aside to protect critical habitat for threatened species and vital watersheds that recharge the aquifers on which South Floridians rely for drinking water. Roads would be cut, trees and other vegetation removed, and five staging areas, including two helicopter pads, constructed.

 The Preserve is not only the home of the endangered Florida panther, but a critical rookery for five colonies of endangered wood storks and home to the shy and diminutive red-cockaded woodpecker, the eastern indigo, and the gopher turtle. 
  
Seismic testing would have permanent and cumulative impacts on wildlife, wetlands, recreational areas, and the water supply. The fractures and fissures created by vibroseis trucks would degrade the wetlands, shallow limestone strata, and base rock.

 In a letter to the U.S. Department of the Interior objecting to the survey, Senator Bill Nelson wrote that the testing “…is troubling as it represents the first step toward fracking. This activity is distinctly at odds with the purpose and best use of a national preserve, and it would be reckless to allow this to move forward.”

 Senator Nelson concluded that “federal, state and local partners have spent billions of dollars working diligently to restore and protect the Everglades, Big Cypress National Preserve, and other valuable ecosystems in Florida. With so many resources devoted to protecting these treasures, approval of oil and gas exploration does not make sense and is a dangerous step in the wrong direction.” 
  
We’re right behind the Senator. We oppose any seismic survey, and urge the National Park Service to conduct a full Environmental Impact Statement including public hearings that will provide it with the substantiated, documented evidence it needs to reject Burnett Oil’s project once and for all. It’s up to us to call on the National Park Service to live up to its stated mission of preserving, conserving, and protecting our natural and cultural resources.

 It has taken two years to get the Park Service to call a meeting that consists of its making a public statement followed by members of the audience moving from station to station asking questions and submitting written comments. That’s how afraid they are of us. And that’s why there will be an open mic at the press conference, a video of which will be sent to the Park Service after the meeting.

 Comment cards are small, so if you do go to the meeting—and I can’t urge you strongly enough to do so—please bring your written comment of up to ten pages in length. And if you can’t possibly attend, you have through December 20th to submit a written comment up to ten pages long to the Park Service here.

 It’s critical for us to show the Park Service just how strong opposition to seismic testing and fracking in Big Cypress National Preserve is, and how utterly committed we are to preserving Florida’s water supply and wildlands. The DEP has already approved Burnett Oil’s proposal, so the National Park Service is our last hope. Please don’t sit this one out.
  
One last word on the significance of your participation: A while back, I asked you to submit a comment to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission as part of a statewide campaign by the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy against FPL’s proposal to build two more nuclear reactors at Turkey Point. It was a last-ditch attempt. The NRC was inundated with over 11,000 comments. It indicated that it was unable to stick to the deadline it had set, and that it would be at least seven months before anything could be decided. This is how it went with Keystone XL—it was delayed and delayed again, until finally it was nixed.

 That’s how important your participation in this campaign is. It could change history.

 Thank you,


Michelle Gale

Thursday, November 19, 2015

NO FRACKING WAY!

from Michelle Gale

Hi All,

Last year, there were two fracking ban bills in the State Legislature, one in the House and one in the Senate. Neither was introduced. The pro-fracking bills were expedited.

This year, despite the fact that we’ve instigated 54 city and county resolutions against fracking in Florida, the same scenario is beginning to play out. We have to stop it.

Please make two critical calls:

1.   One to Senator Charlie Dean, chair of the Senate Committee on Environmental Preservation & Conservation, at 1.866.583.2908, to urge him to introduce SB 166 to ban fracking, and

2.   The other to Representative Steve Crisafulli, Speaker of the House, at 1.888.793.4597, to urge him to introduce HB 19 to ban fracking

A pro-fracking bill is already on its way through the house. It’s up to us to let Senator Dean and Representative Crisafulli know that the commissions that govern 45% of the Floridian population have spoken, and the ban bills must be introduced.

Friday, October 30, 2015

TALLAHASSEE FRACKING BILL

from David Cullen

The following appears on the Florida Report listserv, an email alert system controlled by Sierra Club Florida to keep members aware of legislative doings.  To subscribe to that list and receive regular updates contact Sierra Club Florida Legislative Lobbyist Dave Cullen (cullenasea@aol.com)

Fracking bill up in committee on Tuesday, Nov 3, 2015

Calls Needed to stop a new fracking bill that will:
  • wreak havoc with Florida’s water through excessive and wasteful consumptive use
  • risk chemical pollution underground and/or at the surface
  • continue to enable the use of fossil fuels in a world impacted by GHG driven climate change, and
  • completely preempt local governments’ ability to protect their communities

HB 191 - Regulation of Oil and Gas  by Rep. Ray Rodrigues,  will be heard in the House Agriculture and Natural Resources Subcommittee next Tuesday, November 3 at noon.  Please contact the members of the committee to urge them to vote NO on this bill.  Also, contact your personal Representative and Senator and urge them to stop the bills permitting fracking.   Committee member contact information is below. 

There are currently six fracking bills filed this year.  A brief explanation of each is included at the bottom of this alert.  Please take a minute to go through it so you’ll know which are good, which are bad, and which legislators are behind them.  (The sponsor of the bad bill HB 191 - the subject of this alert, is Rep. Rodrigues (with an ‘s’) who could easily be confused with Rep.Javier Rodriguez (with a ‘z’) the sponsor of a good Constitutional amendment to ban fracking, e.g.)


     House Agriculture and Natural Resources Subcommittee 2016
Rep. Tom Goodson, Chair   850-717-5050      tom.goodson@myfloridahouse.gov
Rep. Jake Raburn, V Chair  850-717-5057      jake.raburn@myfloridahouse.gov
Rep. Jim Boyd                            850-717-5071      jim.boyd@myfloridahouse.gov
Rep. Neil Combee                   850-717-5039      neil.combee@myfloridahouse.gov
Rep. Brad Drake                      850-717-5005      brad.drake@myfloridahouse.gov
Rep. Bobby DuBose                850-717-5094      bobby.dubose@myfloridahouse.gov
Rep. Katie Edwards                850-717-5098      katie.edwards@myfloridahouse.gov
Rep. Larry Lee                           850-717-5084      larry.lee@myfloridahouse.gov
Rep. Ray Pilon                           850-717-5072      ray.pilon@myfloridahouse.gov
Rep. Jimmie Smith                  850-717-5034      jimmie.smith@myfloridahouse.gov
Rep. Cyndi Stevenson            850-717-5017      cyndi.stevenson@myfloridahouse.gov
Rep. Jennifer Sullivan            850-717-5031      jennifer.sullivan@myfloridahouse.gov
Rep. Clovis Watson                 850-717-5020      clovis.watson@myfloridahouse.gov


To find your  legislators paste this address into your browser:



Talking Points
Fracking imposes unnecessary and unacceptable risks on the residents of Florida.  The tremendous use of water that is forever lost due to contamination, the risk of contaminating our aquifers, and the continuing contribution of greenhouse gases to the atmosphere posed by fracking and burning natural gas is unconscionable when energy efficiency and renewable energy offer a clean and safe alternative. 

HB 191:
  • Completely preempts anything to do with oil or gas to the state, including: exploration, development, production, processing, storage, or transportation.  The preemption would apply to existing ordinances as well as prohibiting the adoption of new ones.
  • Uses a definition for “high-pressure well stimulation” that exempts the fracking activities most likely to be used in Florida from any regulation because those techniques, acid fracturing and acid matrix stimulation, are performed at lower pressure and are thereby excluded from the definition in the bill.  These are the techniques most often used in limestone and dolomite geological areas like Florida
  • Exposes municipalities to all oil and gas exploration and production activities inside city limits, (not just fracking) regardless of local government’s wishes by eliminating a provision in current law that permits can only be issued if the governing body of the city passes a resolution in favor of the oil/gas activity,
  • Provides that permits will be issued as soon as rulemaking is complete regardless of what a study required by the bill may reveal,
  • Designates FracFocus as the official chemical disclosure registry while preventing citizens from knowing what is being injected into the ground beneath their feet by use of the Uniform Trade Secrets Act.
Backers of the bill tout it as being a moratorium (a delay before fracking permits are issued.)  Permits won’t be issued right away, but they will be issued as soon as the rulemaking process is complete. And all of the other bad policy in the bill will be effective immediately. The preemption, the vulnerability of cities that oil/gas operators may want to drill in, and of course, the definition of “high-pressure well stimulation” that excludes the most likely methods of fracking for Florida from new regulation will all take effect on Day One.  No new regulations or permitting will be put in place for acid fracturing or acid matrix stimulation and the potential for contamination will occur regardless of whether or not “high-pressure well stimulations” permits are being issued.  The broad preemption language will prevent localities from doinganything about it, and the Trade Secrets provision will prevent residents from finding out what toxic chemicals they may be exposed to.
The bill calls for a study, but only of “high-pressure well stimulation.”  And there is no provision for delay or a change in direction if the study turns up a threat to public health - fracking permits get issued when rulemaking is complete.
Water Use:

Contaminants:
  • Oil and gas service companies used hydraulic fracturing products containing 29 chemicals that are (1) known or possible human carcinogens, (2) regulated under the Safe Drinking Water Act for their risks to human health, or (3) listed as hazardous air pollutants under the Clean Air Act. These 29 chemicals were components of 652 different products used hydraulic fracturing. Chemicals Used in Hydraulic Fracturing U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Commerce and Energy, Minority Staff Report, 2011
  • The National Academy of Sciences discovered that homes within 1 kilometer (2/3 mile) were six times more likely to have six times more methane in their drinking water than those farther away.  Ethane levels were 23 times higher.


Trade Secrets:
  • HB 191 lets well operators claim the chemicals they use are “trade secrets” which means residents, first responders, and medical personnel cannot find out what they are dealing with.  All that is necessary to claim “trade secret” protection is to say the secret is valuable to the well operator and that the well operator is trying to keep it a secret.  688.002 (4) Florida Statutes

Health Impacts:
The New York State Department of Health report states under ‘Health outcomes near HVHF (high volume hydraulic fracturing)Activity:
  • One peer-reviewed study and one university report have presented data indicating statistical associations between some birth outcomes (low birth weight and some congenital defects) and residential proximity of the mother to well pads during pregnancy (Hill, 2012; McKenzie, 2014). Proximity to higher-density HVHF well pad development was associated with increased incidence of congenital heart defects and neural-tube defects in one of the studies (McKenzie, 2014).



Fracking legislation filed for 2016 session:
Good Anti-fracking bills:
There are two bills to ban fracking by statute:

SB 0166 Oil and Natural Gas Production or Recovery  by Sen. Soto has been referred to Environmental Preservation and Conservation; Commerce and Tourism; Community Affairs; Fiscal Policy


HB 0019 Well Stimulation Treatments by Rep. Jenne has been referred to Agriculture and Natural Resources Subcommittee; Energy and Utilities Subcommittee; Agriculture and Natural Resources Appropriations Subcommittee; State Affairs Committee


There are also two good Joint Resolutions to place a constitutional amendment on the ballot to banfracking in the state:

SJR 0358 Hydraulic Fracturing  by Sen. Ring has been referred to Environmental Preservation and Conservation; Judiciary; Rules.

A similar Joint Resolution has been filed by Rep. Javier Rodriguez (with a ‘z’) -
HJR 0453 Well Stimulation by Rep. Rodriguez (with a ‘z’) but has not yet been referred to  committees.

The legislature can place proposed amendments to the state constitution without getting any petitions signed.  The only requirement is that the Resolution proposing the amendment get a 3/5ths vote in each chamber.  (It would also need the approval of 60% of the voters to be adopted.)


Bad Pro-fracking bills:

HB 0191 Regulation of Oil and Gas Resources by Rep. Rodrigues (with an ‘s’) has been referred to to Agriculture and Natural Resources Subcommittee; Agriculture and Natural Resources Appropriations Subcommittee; State Affairs Committee.  (It is the bill up in Agriculture and Natural Resources on Tuesday, November 3.)

SB 0318 Regulation of Oil and Gas Resources by Sen. Richter has been referred to Environmental Preservation and Conservation; Appropriations Subcommittee on General Government; Appropriations.

This year the pro-fracking sponsors have not filed separate ‘trade secrets’ bills and are relying on the process already in statute in Chapter 688 to protect them from having to disclose what toxic chemicals they are injecting into the ground.

David Cullen



Friday, October 23, 2015

FRACKING BENEFITS NOT WORTH COST

'Fracking' benefits not worth costs
October 21, 2015
By Richard C. Silvestri , Fort Myers Beach Bulletin, Fort Myers Beach Observer
           
High pressure well stimulation is most commonly known as "Fracking."

This is a process used to extract hydrocarbons of oil and natural gas from shale layers that are approximately one mile down where the drill can turn horizontally and continue up to two miles. The process uses an average of four million gallons of water. A well can be fracked up to eight times, so on average each well can use 32 million gallons of water, equally one-foot of water over 100 acres.

The source of Fracking water can be natural springs like Silver Springs, ponds, lakes, creeks, rivers, streams or the aquifers that are under all of Florida. To that water is added numerous chemicals which are not revealed and the fossil fuel industry (FFI) refuses to reveal them.

Chemical analysis is easily obtained but the FFI denies any purported chemicals come from their operations and since no base-line analysis has been done, it is hard to prove. Not until recently did the need for this base-line become evident when illnesses and contaminated wells appeared. We know that benzene is one chemical for sure and in Florida, with its porous limestone, hydrofluoric acid is used to dissolve this. Benzene was banned from gasoline by the American Petroleum Institute (API) in the early 1950s due to their own research that concluded it was not safe for human contact. It was used to raise the octane rating of gasoline to eliminate motor "knock."

The Florida Petroleum Council contends, "Fracking is harmless." Yet Fracking and, what other names it goes by, uses benzene within the aquifers. Hydrofluoric Acid is used to etch glass and is so corrosive to glass it is kept in plastic containers. Glass is silicone dioxide, the major component of sand, and is in the soil in various silicon compounds and limestone has many silicon compounds in it.

Once a well is fracked, water, called "flow back," returns through the bore hole. However some 80 percent of the water remains along with the chemicals. The other 20 percent is placed in holding ponds or is deep-well injected at local sewage plants. Therefore, virtually all of this chemical 
additive of millions of gallons is left in the ground.

In addition to the chemicals, a gritty material called "propant" is injected. Propants hold the fissures in the shale open so the hydrocarbons can flow into the bore which is lined with small holes.

These holes are also the method which the pressure from explosives in the well pipe inject more pressure to fracture and crack the shale, hence the verb "to Frack" and its lineage of names such as "Fracking," "Fracked," etc. Addition of these propants creates local air pollution when they are put into the mix at the surface, and they linked to silicosis.

Having traveled through Texas and North Dakota and personally seen the oil wells there and from reports about earthquakes from fracking in Oklahoma, my personal impression is that today most if not all oil and natural gas is extracted by the Fracking process. That goes right along with the scientific consensus that in the USA the "low hanging fruit" or "peak oil" has been exhausted and Fracking is getting at the last drops.

While the FFI reports that the USA has a "mother lode" of natural gas, the global demand will mean we in the USA will have to compete with that demand which will drive up prices domestically. Unfortunately and most importantly, Fracking can devastate Florida's beauty, its agriculture
and its people.

Are the benefits worth the costs?

Richard C. Silvestri is the vice president of Treasure Coast Progressive Alliance. He holds a Bachelor of Science degree in Chemistry from the University of Miami, is a former hazardous materials instructor and a retired chief fire officer.


Sunday, March 29, 2015

HELP STOP FRACKING IN FLORIDA

from Sharon Lux

Recently, a notice to the public was published in our local newspaper regarding seeking permits to the final process by the FDEP to begin exploratory drilling (aka Fracking) in Okeechobee (3193 NE 366th Trail Okeechobee, FL 34972). If a second permit is issued this will allow for non hazardous construction material and non hazardous water to be injected into the well.

To stop this now, sign the petition, "Florida Environmental Protection Agency: Relinquish any and all current and future permits seeking approval from the FDEP (Florida Environmental Protection Agency)."

 Here's the link:



Saturday, March 23, 2013

EVENT MARCH 26

from John Debus
Hi Everyone,
 Want to remind you of our Event this Tuesday 26 March 6:00pm at our NEW location, the American Legion, 810 S. US1, Ft. Pierce Fl. 34950. It will be on Water & Earth, and will be showing short videos on Keystone Pipeline, Hydraulic Fracturing, Deep Well Injection, and Earth Jurisprudence and have open discussions on these issues. So come on out and join in the conversation and check out our new place, much more room inside with plenty of chairs and plenty of parking. Some have asked about bring wine or other drinks. We can NOT bring alcohol drinks in, however they said that you can purchase a drink at the bar to bring in..We will have water, green tea and popcorn available or bring your own non-alcohol drink and snack.
I want to apologize for missing the introductions of the new people and group presentations at the last Event. I've ask the board members to remind me if I forget and get off track. Our new location will not be as strick on our time, so we can hang around a few minutes to socialize. It was hard to get our stuff packed up and out of the last place in time and try to talk with our members. I believe this will help  make our Events much better. I do want to thank Ellen for getting the clubhouse for us in the past, we would never have made it without it.
We will now have to pay for our meeting place, so as long as we continue to grow we should be fine. However we will have a donation jar out to help cut the cost so we can start doing other things.. We are not asking for everyone to donate, nor are we asking for large donations, but if you have some change, it adds up, and would be greatly appreciated..just collecting $5 or $10 of change each meeting would make
a difference..We are hoping to have brochures made up and a TCPA banner made so we can market our organization and start informing people on progressive issues.
A couple events this weekend;
Call to Action; Future of the Port Saturday 23 March 2013  9:00am to 3:00pm
Rally at Ft. Pierce Post Office, Midway Rd. Sunday 24 March 2013  1:00pm to 3:00pm
Locations and more information is on our web-site; tcprogressivealliance.com
Also check out our blog from our website and join in with your comments and blogs.
Also we have another GREAT SPEAKER coming in April...will announce at our Event.
Hope to see you all Tuesday
John


EVENT SCHEDULE
6:00pm, 26 March 2013
American Legion
810 S. US1
Ft. Pierce, Florida

TCPA AGENDA

A. Introductions; 6:00pm to 6:15pm
1. Board
2. New People
3. Groups; Your invited to make a 1-3 minute informal presentation on your mission, current or upcoming events, petition efforts, etc. Bring literature and other materials to
share. Information sharing & networking are one of our purposes of the evening.
4. Special Guess

B. Program: 6:15pm to 7:50pm
Video
*Keystone Pipeline XL podcast   8:51
*Proposed Keystone Pipeline prompts protest march, debate  11:24
Speaker; Jerry Buechler
*What is Fracking   2:11
*The Dangers of Hydrofracking  2:31
*The Fracking song- big oil&gas
*Injection Well Controversy  2:04
* Fracking Wastewater well linked to Ohio earthquake  :34
Speaker: John Debus
*Center for Earth Jurisprudence, overview  9:44
Speaker; Rev. Gregory Wilson

C. “My Opinion”; 7:50pm to 8:00pm

D. Closing of Event.